Showing posts with label Gluten Intolerance Articles. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gluten Intolerance Articles. Show all posts

Monday, January 23, 2012

Enriching Gluten-Free and Wheat Products Doesn’t Make Them Healthy

The Standard American Diet, otherwise referred to as S.A.D., consists of low quality factory farmed meats, over-processed packaged foods with vitamins and minerals added back in, condiments, and a leaf of iceberg lettuce as the vegetable for the day—SAD indeed.

Packaged processed foods made with enriched white flour, like cereals, crackers, pasta, snacks, and bread, make up a large part of most American diets. In fact, Americans eat 31 percent more packaged food than fresh food, and they consume more packaged food per person than their counterparts in nearly all other countries. The 2005 Dietary Guidelines for Americans recommend that individuals should “consume 3 or more ounce-equivalents of whole grain products per day, with the rest of the recommended grains coming from enriched or whole-grain products. In general, at least half of the grains should come from whole grains.”

The 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans recommend that individuals consume at least one-half of all their grains as whole grains (i.e. 3 servings/day; 1 serving = 16 g; about two table spoons). However, dietary intake data from the Continuing Survey of Food Intakes and NHANES indicates that the average whole grain intake is 1 serving/day, with 95% of Americans not meeting their whole grain daily intake recommendations.

How did Americans end up eating only one serving of whole grain a day? First let’s define whole grain. According to the Whole Grains Council: “Whole grains or foods made from them contain all the essential parts and naturally-occurring nutrients of the entire grain seed.”

One serving of whole grain per day happened because food manufacturers tricked consumers into believing that highly processed wheat flour (enriched white flour) is an equal alternative to whole grain flour—which is not the case. To improve its shelf life, white flour has been stripped of all its nutrients and then “enriched” with a few vitamins and minerals to make it appear like a healthy option.

Processed foods like white flour are frequently “enriched” and “fortified.” In “enriched foods,” the nutrients are removed during the initial processing, then later in the process, synthetic nutrients are added back. With “fortified foods,” additional nutrients that were not originally in these foods are added to make the food appear more nutritious. For instance, most of us have had vitamin D fortified milk or calcium and vitamin D fortified orange juice. Vitamin D and calcium do not occur naturally in OJ.

When you buy enriched or fortified products, you are purchasing products that contain cheap vitamins and minerals that are poorly absorbed by the body. Only small amounts of the removed nutrients are replaced, and the synergy between these nutrients is lost. Food in its natural form contains protein, fiber, healthy fats, vitamins and minerals—all of which are present for a reason. These nutrients work together harmoniously in the food and in our bodies.  

While enriching and fortifying foods may sound like a good idea, adding back the vitamins and minerals that were removed in processing will never recreate the benefits of eating whole grain foods. Bottom line: You can’t fool Mother Nature; you also can’t fool your body.

One of the biggest problems with processed food is that many of the healthy nutrients taken out during manufacturing are simply lost. For instance, when whole grains are refined, the bran and the coat of the grain are often removed—and with them go nutrients like fiber, antioxidants, oils, lignins, phytochemicals, vitamins, and minerals. During the enrichment process, a few of these nutrients are artificially added back. But even after enrichment, the final product is almost always less nutritious than the whole grain you started with.

For example, take whole grain wheat flour compared to white enriched unbleached flour (see the chart below). Processing the whole grain flour reduced the amount of all minerals, except iron, which was added back in to enrich the flour. The iron content is slightly higher in the enriched flour, but the synthetic form of iron used in enriched flour, ferric orthophosphate, is not easily absorbed by the body, so it is essentially worthless. (See below for more information about this issue.) And check out the fiber content—dramatically reduced in the white flour product.







































































































Minerals

whole-grain


 

white enriched unbleached


 






Calcium, Ca (mg)

40.800


 

18.750


   
Iron, Fe (mg)

4.656


 

5.800


   
Magnesium, Mg (mg)

165.600


 

27.500


   
Phosphorus, P (mg)

415.200


 

135.000


   
Potassium, K (mg)

486.000


 

133.750


   
Sodium, Na (mg)

6.000


 

2.500


   
Zinc, Zn (mg)

3.516


 

0.875


   
Copper, Cu (mg)

0.458


 

0.180


   
Manganese, Mn (mg)

4.559


 

0.853


   
Selenium, Se (mcg)

84.840


 

42.375


   

Fiber (gm)                                                  15                                                                               3

 

One big advantage to eating foods in their whole unprocessed form is that you are getting the natural synergy of all the nutrients together. Michael Pollan introduces the idea of “food synergy” in his book, In the Defense of Food. Webster’s Dictionary defines synergy as, “The interaction of two or more agents or forces so that their combined effect is greater than the sum of their individual effects."

This definition was proven in a May 2011 study in the Journal of Nutrition. Researchers observed that consuming whole grains reduces mortality from all causes. However, when scientists “identified” all the beneficial nutrients in whole grain, they could not explain why these beneficial effects occurred. The scientists concluded that, "the various grains and their parts interact synergistically." 

In addition to synergy, the types of vitamins and minerals added back in to enrich or fortify processed food products are often cheap substitutes for the real thing. If the vitamins and minerals that are bound to inexpensive and unabsorbable ingredients, they do the body no good. A small portion of these added nutrients are absorbed by the body, but certainly not to the extent that is stated on the label. For instance, the vitamin D found in fortified milk is vitamin D2, also known as ergocalciferol. This form of vitamin D is less potent and absorbable than vitamin D3. According to a study in The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, Vitamin D2 (ergocalciferol) should not be regarded as a nutrient suitable for supplementation or fortification. The same also applies to the B vitamins and other minerals used in enrichment and fortification of foods. Not only have processed foods lost the interactions between ingredients that occur naturally in whole foods, but the synthetic nutrients used to enrich these food products are poorly absorbed by the body.

Another concern with enriched flours and gluten-free products not made from whole grain flours is their effect on blood sugar levels. Enriched flour products and gluten-free flour products that lack whole grains tend to be higher on the glycemic index. In contrast, foods made from whole grains tend to be lower on the glycemic index. The glycemic index (GI) is a measure of the effects of carbohydrates on blood sugar levels. Carbohydrates that break down quickly during digestion and release glucose rapidly into the bloodstream have a high GI; carbohydrates that break down more slowly, gradually releasing glucose into the bloodstream, have a low GI.    

Whole grain flours contain higher amounts of fiber, protein, and fat, which slow down the digestive process and reduce the rate at which sugars enter the bloodstream. This moderated increase and decrease in blood sugar results in a lower glycemic index and allows for better insulin control and blood sugar balance. A diet containing primarily low glycemic index foods is responsible for many health benefits: reduced cholesterol levels, reduced risk of heart disease, lower incidence of cancer and type 2 diabetes, and healthy weight loss.

In the case of many gluten-free food products (breads and pizza in particular), white flours and starches are used to supplement whole grain flours. For example, instead of just using whole grain flour such as brown rice flour or buckwheat flour, many manufacturers cut corners by adding less expensive white rice flour, potato starch, tapioca starch, and corn starch.  The result is unhealthy gluten-free products that are low in fiber, protein, vitamins, minerals, antioxidants, alpha linoleic acid, lignins, phytochemicals, and other nutrients—and high in calories and simple carbs.

Why would food manufacturers encourage the gluten-intolerant community to heal and nourish their bodies on inferior, unhealthy products? The obvious answer is money, which is all the more reason why consumers of gluten-free foods need to become better educated about the products they purchase.

As a nutritionist, the word “frustration” doesn’t begin to explain how I feel about the creation of nutritionally void gluten-free products. Let’s just say it was strong enough that I created my own line of whole grain gluten-free products.  

Eating enriched foods (gluten-free or otherwise) is not a healthy choice. The promise of added vitamins and minerals may sound like a good idea, but as Gertrude Stein said once, “There’s no ‘there’ there.” The low quality vitamins and minerals added back in do not compare to the natural ones that were removed. Removing the fiber, protein, and good fats raises any food’s glycemic index and reduces the benefits found in whole foods, such as whole grains.

Eating nourishing food every day is one choice you can make that will create an immediate difference in your overall health and in how you feel. If you are looking to improve your health by eating better, then you need to make smart choices.

Follow these points to eat whole grain:

  • If you eat wheat, look for whole wheat products and avoid the enriched white flour ones. Be skeptical, even if the packaging says it contains “whole grain wheat products” because it may only contain a very small amount. Please visit Whole Grains Council’s Whole Grains 101 page for more information.

  • If you eat gluten-free, find products with ingredients using whole grain flours or packaging that says 100% whole grain.


Here is a list of gluten-free whole grains and whole grains that contain gluten:



























































Gluten Free Whole GrainsWhole Grains that Contain Gluten
AmaranthBarley
Buckwheat  Bulgur
Corn (whole cornmeal and popcorn)Cracked Wheat
Millet  Durum
Oats (oatmeal), find gluten-free oatsEinkorn
QuinoaEmmer
Rice (brown and colored)Farro
Sorghum (milo)Kamut®
TeffRye
Wild RiceSpelt
 Triticale
 Wheat
 Wheat berries

 

Wednesday, November 30, 2011

Celiac Disease and Gluten Intolerance: Does Time Heal All Wounds?

As the saying goes, “time heals all wounds.” But what if you have been suffering with celiac disease or gluten sensitivity (GS) for decades and just want to feel better today? Besides a gluten-free diet, is there anything else you can do to enhance the healing process?

After receiving a celiac or GS diagnosis, most patients leave their doctor’s office with instructions to adhere to a strict gluten-free diet—and that’s it. While it’s wonderful to have a definitive diagnosis and not to have to take medication for the rest of your life, it’s also important to know that there are powerful over-the-counter tools at your disposal.

I frequently encourage newly diagnosed clients to start a course of nutritional supplements for six months to a year depending on the severity of their condition. Not only do the nutritional supplements listed below promote intestinal health and healing, they can actually accelerate your recovery.

Without a small intestine biopsy, it is difficult to estimate how ravaged your intestines are. Since biopsies are no longer required to diagnose celiac disease, most newly diagnosed patients are in the dark about the condition of their digestive track. According to the National Institutes of Health, diet alone will heal existing intestinal damage and prevent further damage. Yet, the amount of time it takes to heal completely varies depending on a number of factors, particularly age. For example, in children, the small intestine can take three to six months to heal; however, in adults, it may take several years before healing is complete.

While waiting for the gut to heal, many of the nutrients you consume are lost. A healthy intestine has an abundance of villi (tiny, finger-like projections that increase the intestinal surface area), which allows for the absorption of nutrients into the bloodstream. With celiac disease these villi are flattened and proper absorption of nutrients is compromised. The continued malabsorption of nutrients such as calcium, magnesium, vitamin D, B vitamins, and omega-3 fatty acids can contribute to mood disorders, lower energy levels, poor bone health, insomnia, attention problems, and a host of other issues.

Until recently, conventional medical wisdom presumed that only those with celiac disease suffered from severe intestinal degradation, the kind that destroys your villi. In the spring of 2011, however, Dr. Alessio Fasano completed a research study that found differences in levels of intestinal permeability and the expression of genes regulating the immune responses in the gut mucosa possibly associated with gluten sensitivity. What this study revealed is that gluten sensitivity and celiac disease are part of the same spectrum of gluten-related disorders. Meaning that those with gluten sensitivity suffer from intestinal permeability issues similar to those with celiac disease, but to a lesser degree. In other words, people with gluten sensitivity—not just those with celiac disease—have absorption issues caused by an immune response to gluten.

For the people with celiac disease and gluten sensitivity who more than likely have intestinal inflammation and permeability issues, the question remains: “How to return the digestive track back to normal as quickly as possible?”

Nutrition Supplements to Support Healing

The following nutrition supplements are effective and work independently of each other. These supplements also complement each other, so taking them together can help heal many aspects of the gut at once. In my experience as a Registered Dietitian working with patients who are afflicted with gluten issues, I have found that glutamine, probiotics, and fish oil (in that order) are my “Top Three” choices. Before you begin taking these, or any supplements, I encourage you to have a consultation with a dietitian who has experience with gluten disorders. 

Glutamine is the most abundant amino acid in the body. It is a protein building block and is involved in more metabolic processes than any other amino acid. Glutamine also serves as a source of fuel for the cells lining the intestine and can promote healing in these cells when they are damaged by gluten. How much Glutamine you should take depends upon several factors. I suggest you consult a dietitian for the dosage that is right for you.

Probiotics are live bacteria that improve the intestinal microbial balance and enhance overall health. They are the “good” bacteria found in the gastrointestinal track. Inflammation or toxins in the gut can disrupt the balance between “good” and “bad” bacteria. Probiotics may be taken to restore a healthy balance and assist in the removal of toxins created by gluten insensitivity or celiac disease. In addition, a preventative dose of probiotics is a good idea as these microbes promote immune health, and they are frequently absent in modern diets. Probiotics come as capsules, tablets, liquids, powders and contain many different strains of bacteria. Be sure to purchase your probiotics from a reputable company that ensures the potency and efficacy of their products. Contact these companies for documentation stating probiotic viability and research studies using the strains in their formulas—or visit their websites. I normally recommend that my patients receive a daily dose of at least 10 billion (or more) live, viable, organisms per gram containing: Lactobacillus acidophilus, Lactobacillus bifidobacteria, Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus bulgaricus.

Omega 3 fatty acids are comprised of the fatty acids EPA and DHA and are found in fish and fish oil supplements. These essential fats are not made by the body and must be eaten or taken in supplement form to ensure the body’s adequate functioning. In addition to reducing inflammation, these fats help to support healthy heart, brain, skin, and bone function. Significant health problems may result when these nutrients are not adequately absorbed. I recommend a dosage of 1,000 mg EPA and 1,000 mg DHA be taken daily from a high quality product with low mercury and toxin levels.

Digestive enzymes aid the body in digesting and breaking down proteins, fats, and carbohydrates. Digestive enzymes from either animal or plant sources should be taken an empty stomach, 20 minutes before meals or snacks. Enzymes help break down food into forms that the body can use. When the gut is damaged a condition called “leaky gut syndrome” occurs, and undigested food particles can pass through the intestinal wall into the blood stream in a form the body cannot use. These unusable food particles then activate an immune response because the body has detected an “invader.” This immune response adds inflammation to the ongoing food sensitivity issues. Digestive enzymes assist in breaking food down into the right form for the body to use. In general, plant- or microbial-derived enzymes are more effective and work in more areas of your digestive system than their animal-derived counterparts.

Anti-inflammatory herbal formulas can help reduce inflammation and promote healing. Look for herbs like turmeric, aloe vera, ginger, and boswellia in formulas or by themselves as a part of your healing regime. Again, working with a dietitian to decide dosages and which combination of these herbs would be most beneficial to you is recommended.

What to Consider if You Are Not Getting Better

There are some people with celiac disease that show no improvement on a gluten-free diet. One of the most common reasons for a poor response to the diet is that small amounts of gluten are still being consumed. Hidden sources of gluten include medications, additives such as modified food starch, preservatives, and stabilizers made with wheat. Additionally, those with severe sensitivities may not be healing because of cross contamination caused by production facilities. Most corn and rice products are produced in factories that also manufacture wheat products. For some people, even these minute amounts of cross contamination can add up. Some people should only consume packaged foods from GF certified facilities, or in extreme cases, consume no packaged foods at all.

Some people with celiac disease continue to have intestinal flare ups despite being on a strict gluten-free diet. People with this condition, known as refractory celiac disease, have severely damaged intestines that heal very slowly—if at all. Because their intestines are not absorbing enough nutrients, these celiac sufferers may need to receive many of their nutrients intravenously.

Cross reactivity to some gluten-free grains can also be a problem. Intolerances to grains that do not contain gluten, which people on gluten-free diet tend to eat more of, can also develop. Many times these secondary intolerances develop because of gut permeability and the body’s response to foreign material outside the gut lining, where it is not suppose to be. Cyrex Labs offers a Gluten Cross Reactive Foods Test that looks at the 24 most common foods that cross-react with gluten. This test will help you identify and avoid other foods that are preventing you from healing and feeling better.

In my experience, time does heal these wounds, but the amount of time varies widely from person to person. I have seen many people’s symptoms—in particular, severe cases that have gone unresolved for decades— abate faster and more thoroughly thanks to additional supplementation. Any time the gut has undergone stress, the supplements mentioned above can be of benefit—and always be mindful when purchasing supplements to be sure they are gluten-free.

About the Author:

Julie McGinnis, MS, RD, has been involved in the field of nutrition for twenty years and started work in a conservative hospital setting as a registered dietitian. Her company, The Gluten Free Bistro, is the culmination of years of nutrition experience and living gluten-free combined with a genuine desire to provide a nutritious product for the celiac and gluten intolerant communities. Visit Julie McGinnis at www.theglutenfreebistro.com

 

Friday, October 7, 2011

Meatless Monday and Wheatless Wednesday-So What’s For Dinner?

Whether for ecological purposes or healthy lifestyles, less is definitely more. Think about the simple water conservation changes you may have made recently, like turning off the spigot while brushing your teeth, or the healthy choices you’ve made like reducing your overall calorie intake. These same types of choices can also be made when it comes to choosing whether to eat meat or wheat for dinner.

Recently, Americans have definitely been leaning toward the “more is better” lifestyle choice. For example, in 2010, 12 out of 50 states had obesity rates of 30 percent or more. The Centers for Disease Control estimates that as of 2010, 79 million Americans have prediabetes—which works out to an alarming 35 percent of the adults over 20 in the United States have this condition. Prediabetes is a serious condition that significantly increases the risk of Type II diabetes, heart disease, and stroke. Being overweight, inactive, and not getting enough sleep are part the package for developing prediabetes.

One way to reduce the risk of prediabetes, or perhaps prevent it altogether, is to adopt a vegetarian diet (even adopting a partial vegetarian diet has show to reduce the risk). The American Dietetic Association’s position, published in the July issue of the Journal of the American Dietetic Association, represents the association’s official stance on vegetarian diets: “A well balanced vegetarian diet is often associated with health advantages including lower blood cholesterol levels, lower risk of heart disease, lower blood pressure levels and lower risk of hypertension and type 2 diabetes.” What you eat every day has a huge impact on your health, and choosing to eat less meat and wheat might be right in synch with what your body needs.

Along those lines, there are two new slogans-of-the-week that are gaining momentum: “Meatless Monday” and “Wheatless Wednesday.” According to FoodNavigator-USA.com, awareness of the ‘Meatless Monday’ campaign has recently reached more than half of Americans (50.22 percent of 2,000 American adults contacted in a nationally representative sample were aware of the campaign—up from 30 percent awareness six months ago). “Wheatless Wednesday” started at The Sink, an eatery in Boulder, Colorado, as a way to offer gluten-free dishes one day a week. Today, gluten-free menus are available every day of the week in many national chains and local eateries.

Meatless Monday

Let’s start with Meatless Monday. The inspiration came from a February 11, 2011 Oprah show where the staff was challenged by Oprah to eat a vegan diet for a week. Kathy Freston, author of Veganist was featured in the show and she helped folks with recipes and products to buy to adhere to a vegan diet. Freston is a New York Times best-selling author who writes about healthy living and conscious eating. Her intention is to support and inform anyone interested in “leaning in” to eating and living consciously. She says, “A veganist is someone who moves toward eating a plant based diet so that they are as physically healthy as they can be, environmentally friendly, and a kind and thoughtful human being.”

If you’re at all skeptical about what impact eating a vegetarian diet would have on your health, our economy, or global environmental concerns, take a look at the following information from Alternet.org.

If everyone in the U.S. chose to eat a vegetarian diet for just one day we would save:

  • 100 billion gallons of water, enough to supply all the homes in New England for almost 4 months

  • 1.5 billion pounds of crops otherwise fed to livestock, enough to feed New Mexico for a year

  • 70 million gallons of gas—enough to fuel all the cars of Canada and Mexico with plenty to spare

  • 3 million acres of land, an area more than twice the size of Delaware

  • 33 tons of antibiotics


If everyone went vegetarian just for one day, the U.S. would prevent:

  • Greenhouse gas emissions equivalent to 1.2 million tons of CO2, equal to France’s CO2 production

  • 3 million tons of soil erosion and $70 million in resulting economic damages

  • 4.5 million tons of animal excrement

  • Almost 7 tons of ammonia emissions, a major air pollutant


According to The Environmental Defense Fund, if every American skipped one meal of chicken per week and substituted vegetarian foods instead, the carbon dioxide savings would be the same as taking more than half a million cars off U.S. roads What an easy way to reduce your carbon footprint.

How’s that for proof that eating a vegetarian, or the stricter vegan, diet for just one day has some serious global impact?

What Should I Eat?

Let’s say you took the above information to heart and decided to make some changes in how you and your family eats, the question then becomes, “What’s for dinner?” If you’re going to embrace the idea of Meatless Monday, you will probably need to put more thought into what’s on the daily menu. Fruits, vegetables, dried beans and peas, grains, seeds, eggs, dairy products and nuts are all part of a vegetarian diet. If you’re not used to making dinner out of these ingredients, your first attempt might prove a little daunting and this is where some good recipe suggestions really come in handy.

An easy place to start is to modify your favorite recipes and make them without meat. So, if you make meat lasagna, substitute spinach or another vegetable in its place. Try making veggie pizza, quesadillas, ravioli, stir fry with organic tofu, veggie soup with a grilled cheese sandwich, quiche, veggie burgers … the list goes on and on. Today, there are tons of great blogs with even more recipes to help you along. Try the Vegetarian Times Blog or The Lazy Vegetarian for great menu ideas. I would also consider The Post Punk Kitchen, International Vegetarian Union, and The Family Kitchen.

Where’s the Wheat?

Now for those with celiac disease and gluten sensitivity, Wheatless Wednesday is 24:7:365. To abate symptoms and improve health, wheat, which is one of the major grains that contains gluten, must be completely omitted from the diet (along with barley, rye, oats, spelt, and sprouted grains). For those looking to decrease the amount the wheat they consume in an effort to cut back on gluten—or maybe just eat more vegetables—one day a week is a great way to start.

Most of the wheat grown today has been genetically modified to be drought resistant and to contain more gluten. The increase in gluten content was intended to make baked goods chewier and more delicious; unfortunately for some of us, it has turned a grain that was already difficult to digest into something that is utterly indigestible. For more information on how wheat has changed over time, visit my article “Gluten Then and Now.”

What Should I Eat Instead of Wheat?

Here is a list of some gluten-free alternative grains that you can use instead of wheat:

  •  Brown Rice Flour has more nutritional value than whole wheat flour. Brown rice flour has three times the vitamin B6 of whole wheat flour and is has equal or more values for vitamins and minerals. This flour also contains alpha-linolenic acid, which is the precursor to making omega-3 fatty acids.

  • Buckwheat is actually made from fruit seeds and is related to rhubarb; it is not an actual cereal grain. Buckwheat is a very good source of magnesium, manganese, along with other vitamins and minerals. One cup of buckwheat flour supplies 75 percent of daily value for magnesium. Buckwheat has protein and fiber content similar to whole wheat flour, and, contains two flavonoids with significant health-promoting actions: rutin and quercetin. This flour also contains alpha-linolenic acid, which is the precursor to making omega-3 fatty acids. Like other cover crops, buckwheat enriches the soil with humus. Buckwheat grows well even in poor soils, making nutrients more available to subsequent plantings. The dense growth shades out weeds and the white flowers play host to beneficial insects such as syrphid flies and ladybugs.

  • While Coconut Flour is not a grain it is a powerhouse of fiber and protein and is low in carbohydrates. Since the rate of allergies to this tree nut is so rare it is considered to be hypo-allergenic. However, this can be a potential allergen for some people. Coconut flour is also great for baking. Although it is classified by the FDA as part of the tree nut family, it is actually in the palm family.

  • Whole Grain Sorghum is an ancient, drought resistant cereal grain grown worldwide. Recent research has shown that sorghum may have several components that could positively impact human health. Some sorghum strains have been found to be high in antioxidants—even higher than blueberries. In addition, the wax surrounding the sorghum grain contains compounds called policosanolsthat have been found in research to reduce cholesterol.

  • Quinoa has an amazing grain and contains all nine essential amino acids making it a complete protein. In addition to protein, quinoa is a very good source of manganese as well as a good source of magnesium, iron, copper and phosphorus.

  • Millet is one of the oldest grains and although it is often used in birdseed it is great for people to eat too. Millet is 15% protein, contains high amounts of fiber, B-complex vitamins including niacin, thiamin, and riboflavin, the essential amino acid methionine, lecithin, and some vitamin E. It is particularly high in the minerals iron, magnesium, phosphorous, and potassium.

  • Amaranth seed is high in protein and contains good amounts of the two amino acids lysine and methionine. Amaranth contains 3 times the amount of fiber as whole wheat and contains calcium (twice the calcium of milk), iron, potassium, phosphorus, and vitamins A and C.

  • Oats are gluten-free but because of high rates of cross contamination in manufacturing, gluten intolerant people should buy the gluten-free variety to ensure safety. Oats contain both soluble and insoluble fiber, which is great for promoting digestion and lowering cholesterol. The fiber in oats also balances blood sugar and they are good source of potassium and other minerals.


If you want to attempt some gluten-free baking, I recommend a gluten-free all-purpose flour mix because individual gluten-free flours cannot be substituted one-for-one with all-purpose wheat flour. Again, there are many gluten-free blogs with wonderful recipes:  www.theglutenfreebistro.com/blog, http://www.cybelepascal.com, http://www.elanaspantry.com, www.glutenfreerecipebox.com .

Today, there are also many gluten-free convenience foods, like: pizza, pasta, frozen dinners, soups, breads, and waffles, just to name a few.

If you want to combine Meatless Mondays with Wheatless Wednesdays, check out Carol Fenster’s, 125 Gluten-Free Vegetarian Recipes!

I challenge you to try to some new meal ideas. The environmental affects of these changes alone demonstrate how small changes can have a global impact. By trying new foods and eating less meat, we all benefit, and you may find that you enjoy Meatless Monday a few more days per week. As you make changes to your diet, take notice of any other changes to your waistline, digestion, mood, skin, and sleep habits. By eliminating food that does not work for your body and mind, you may just find that you feel better. Less may feel like more!

Monday, September 5, 2011

Celiac Disease and Gluten Intolerance Testing- Accurate or Misleading?

Jane G. made an appointment to see me after being diagnosed with Hashimoto’s Thyroiditis (an autoimmune disease of the thyroid with links to celiac disease) and suffering from years of gastrointestinal issues. I reviewed Jane’s medical history and found that not only does she have Hashimoto’s and GI complaints, but she also suffers with inflammation in her joints and anemia (low iron). Suspecting that gluten intolerance was at the root of all these conditions, I suggested Jane adopt a gluten-free diet.

Immediately, I encountered resistance to this suggestion. Jane comes from an Italian-American family, and she lived for good Italian food. In order to even begin contemplating life without pasta and pizza, Jane really needed concrete medical evidence. I recommended that she undergo a new test from Cyrex Labs for gluten reactivity, complete with a comprehensive autoimmunity profile. Unfortunately, this test costs $369 and is not normally covered by insurance. Jane told me she could not afford that test or the appointment with a doctor outside her network. Instead, she made an appointment to get a Celiac Panel blood test done by her in-network physician.

When Jane’s results came back negative, her physician told her that she did not need to follow a gluten-free diet. She was relieved and excited, but she also told me she knew something was still wrong because of her ongoing gastrointestinal symptoms. I convinced her to go gluten-free for two weeks and see if she felt any relief. By the end of the first week, her gastrointestinal symptoms had gone away. Her question to me then became, “Do I have gluten sensitivity? Was the test a false negative? What should I do?”

Blood Tests

The most common blood test requested by doctors is the Celiac Panel. This test measures both your immune system’s response to gluten and whether there is damage to the intestinal tissue. The Celiac Panel consists of tests for the following: Anti-gliadin antibodies (AGA) for both IgA and IgG (IgA and IgG have a roll in controlling the immune system); anti-endomysial antibodies (EMA)—IgA; anti-tissue transglutaminase antibodies (tTG)—IgA, and total IgA level.

According to Dr. Thomas O’Bryan (an expert and lecturer about gluten intolerance), this test records a false negative 7 out of 10 times. These false negatives are due in part to the physician’s interpretation as well as the patient’s condition at the time of the test. Physicians may interpret the test as negative if the test for intestinal tissue damage (anti tTG and EMA) is negative—even if the blood test results indicate a positive immune reaction. The intestinal tissue tests will only come back positive if there is severe damage or atrophy to this tissue—the kind found in end-stage celiac disease. If there is only partial atrophy, the accuracy of this test goes down to 27-30 percent.

Another issue with the Celiac Panel test is that it does not account for those with IgA deficiency, which occurs 10 to 15 times more commonly among people with celiac disease than the general population. Patients with IgA deficiency will lack IgA antibodies, so this blood panel shows up negative. In addition, this panel only screens for one problematic portion of the gluten protein (alpha gliadin), when there are approximately 60 problematic portions. If you have an intolerance to one of the other 50+ proteins in gluten besides alpha gliadin, this test will also come back as negative. Dr. Vicki Petersen, author of The Gluten Effect, believes physicians are misdiagnosing 50 percent of the population according to these false negatives.

As we are learning, there is a spectrum of gluten intolerance from slight to severe, and these tests do not pick up everyone’s sensitivities.

Celiac Disease vs. Gluten Sensitivity

Dr. Alessio Fasano, MD, medical director of the Center for Celiac Research at the University of Maryland, does recommend that patients get blood tests for celiac disease; however, if those tests are negative, Dr. Fasano recommends getting tested for a traditional IgE-mediated allergy to wheat. If that test is also negative, he asks his patients to try a gluten-free diet for a period of 2-4 weeks and see if their symptoms abate. If they do, Dr. Fasano considers this lo-tech de facto positive result the best test of gluten sensitivity available today.

Dr. Fasano recently completed a research study that demonstrated gluten-sensitivity without the presence of celiac disease does exist. The research confirmed that gluten sensitivity is different from celiac disease at both the molecular level and in the immune system’s response. Fasano and his co-authors have demonstrated that gluten sensitivity and celiac disease are part of a same spectrum of gluten-related disorders.

“Imagine gluten ingestion on a spectrum, said Dr. Fasano. At one end, you have people with celiac disease, who cannot tolerate one crumb of gluten in their diet. At the other end, you have the lucky people who can eat pizza, beer, pasta and cookies — and have no ill effects whatsoever. In the middle, there is this murky area of gluten reactions, including gluten sensitivity. This is where we are looking for answers about how to best diagnose and treat this recently identified group of gluten-sensitive individuals.”

Genetic Components

As an autoimmune disease, celiac disease is the consequence of the interplay between genes and the environment (gluten). Two genes, HLA DQ2 and/or HLA DQ8 are absolutely necessary to develop celiac disease. Since one third of the general population have one of these genes, the presence of DQ2 or DQ8 does not, by itself, mean that the person will develop celiac disease; rather, that they have a genetic predisposition for celiac disease. Dr. Kenneth Fine’s research at Enterolab shows that there are several more genes linked to the possible development of celiac disease, gluten sensitivity, and other gluten-related conditions.

Stool and Salivary Tests

Other ways to test for celiac disease and gluten sensitivity include stool test and salivary tests. These tests can be ordered on-line and performed at home without a doctor ordering the test. Enterolab’s unique test screens for gluten sensitivity, as well as for many other antigenic food sensitivities. Enterolab’s method uses stool rather than blood as the testing substrate because the immunologic reactions to gluten proteins occur in the intestinal tract, and not in the blood. Enterolab’s salivary test also identifies the presence of genes associated with celiac disease and gluten sensitivity. All you have to do is swab the inside of your cheek and send it in.

 

Small Intestine Biopsy

A more invasive test for celiac disease is small intestine biopsy. With other, less invasive, methods of testing available today, I do not recommend biopsies. In a recent study, Adherence to biopsy guidelines increases celiac disease diagnosis, led by Dr. Benjamin Lebwohl, MD, MS, a gastroenterologist at the Celiac Disease Center at Columbia University Medical Center, in New York found that 65 percent of patients undergoing a biopsy of the small intestine do not have the recommended number of samples (4) to diagnose celiac disease. The study, published in the July 2011 issue of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy, analyzed a national database of biopsy specimens. More than 100,000 patients had a biopsy of the small intestine, but only 35 percent of them had at least four samples taken, which is the number recommended by the American Medical Association. Adhering to the recommended four biopsy samples increases the rate of diagnosis of celiac disease seven-fold. According to Dr. Peter Green, Director of the Celiac Center Columbia University Medical Center, who was also a co-author on the paper, "In this study, we identified just one of the factors contributing to the high rate of under-diagnosis of celiac disease in the United States. We plan on studying other physician-related factors that may also be operative."

Jane G.

Today, Jane G. is doing well. Her GI complaints cleared up after one week on a gluten-free diet. She continued on the diet, and within a month, her energy levels improved and her joint pain was significantly reduced.  She began to embrace her new way of life and realized that her anemia would take a little longer to resolve as her intestines healed and began properly absorbing nutrients again. However, her thyroid condition will remain, because once that sort of damage is done to an organ via an autoimmune response, it is hard to recover. Still, in most cases, preventing the body from attacking itself will stop the condition from getting worse.

To Test or Not to Test: Let Your Body Be Your Guide

If testing for gluten sensitivity helps you feel confident that you are doing the right thing and not overlooking any additional health problems, then test away; however, if going gluten-free makes you feel better, then don’t worry about your test results. The slightest sensitivity to gluten can cause many health problems and the only definitive way to rid yourself of them is to stop eating gluten.

If you think you might be gluten sensitive, but you’re not sure, there is a useful questionnaire at Health Now Medical that can help you get started. Also, visit thegluten free girl  for a complete list of safe and forbidden foods plus a list of medications and health problems associated with gluten sensitivity.

 

By Julie McGinnis, MS, RD, Certified Herbalist

Wednesday, July 27, 2011

Gluten, Then and Now

by Julie McGinnis, MS, RD

Over the past decade, the frequency of conversations about gluten intolerance (GI) and celiac disease (CD) in the United States has gone from almost unheard of to commonplace. Chances are your local supermarket sells dozens of items labeled “gluten free” where none existed five years ago. Restaurants and school lunch programs frequently offer gluten-free alternatives. What happened?

Before I dive into that discussion, I want to clarify some terms to minimize confusion. "Gluten" is the general term for a mixture of tiny protein fragments (called polypeptides), which are found in cereal grains such as wheat, rye, barley, spelt, faro, and kamut. Gluten is classified in two groups: prolamines and glutelins. The most troublesome component of gluten is the prolamine gliadin. Gliadin is the cause of the painful inflammation in gluten intolerance and instigates the immune response and intestinal damage found in celiac disease. Although both conditions have similar symptoms (pain, gas, bloating, diarrhea), or sometimes no gastrointestinal symptoms at all, celiac disease is an autoimmune reaction to gluten that can cause severe degradation of the small intestine; whereas, gluten intolerance/sensitivity is an inability to digest gliadin with no damage to the intestines.

The medical community’s use of improved diagnostic tools (saliva, blood, and stool tests; and bowel biopsies) as well as self-diagnosis by aware individuals has certainly contributed to the swelling ranks of people afflicted with these maladies; however, that’s not the whole story. A combination of hybridized grains, America’s growing appetite for snacks and fast food, and the genetics of gluten intolerance and celiac disease have brought discussions of these once uncommon conditions front and center.  

Again, what happened?

New evidence indicates that the hybrid versions of grains we eat today contain significantly more gluten than traditional varieties of the same grains. Experts such as Dr. Alessio Fasano, medical director of the Center for Celiac Research at the University of Maryland School of Medicine, believe this recent increase in the amount of gluten in our diet has given rise to the number of people suffering from gluten intolerance and celiac disease.

According to Fasano, “The prevalence of celiac disease in this country is soaring partly because changes in agricultural practices have increased gluten levels in crops.” He further states, “We are in the midst of an epidemic.”

For example, the ancient wheat that Moses ate was probably very different from our wheat today. Moses lived about 3,500 years ago, when wheat, spelt, and barley were all popular grains. Modern wheat varieties, however, have been bred to grow faster, produce bigger yields, harvest more efficiently, and bake better bread. The downside to today’s hybridized cereal grains is that they contain more gluten.  

Celiac disease was once considered a rare malady and was estimated to have afflicted approximately 1 in 2,000 people in the United States. According to research done by the Mayo Clinic, CD is four times more common today that it was five decades ago. This increase is due to increased awareness and diagnostics, and the estimate today is that 1 out of every 133 people in the United States has celiac disease. To read more facts and figures please read The University of Chicago Celiac Disease center at http://www.uchospitals.edu/pdf/uch_007937.pdf   

Here are estimates for other parts of the world:

  • 3 in 100: United Kingdom

  • 1 in 370: Italy

  • 1 in 122: Northern Ireland

  • 1 in 99: Finland

  • 1 in 133: United States

  • Once thought rare for African-, Hispanic- and Asian-Americans, current estimates in these populations: 1 in 236

  • 1 in 30 are estimated to have gluten intolerance in the United States.


More than 6,000 years before Moses was born, an agricultural revolution took place in the Middle East that allowed humans to embrace farming (sowing and harvesting wild seeds), herding, and other forms of agriculture and move away from our hunter-fisher-gatherer ancestors. This was the first major introduction of gluten into the human diet.

According to Dr. Loren Cordain, PhD, author of The Paleo Diet, “The foods that agriculture brought us—cereals, dairy products, fatty meats, salted foods, and refined sugars and oils- proved disastrous for our Paleolithic bodies…. studies of the bones and teeth early farmers revealed that they had more infectious diseases, more childhood mortality, shorter life spans, more osteoporosis, rickets, and other bone mineral density disorders than their ancestors thanks to the cereal-based diet. They were plagued with vitamin and mineral deficiencies and developed cavities in their teeth.”

In other words, people traded their health for sustainable food sources and a less nomadic way of life.

Two hundred years ago, the global diet received another big injection of gluten with the birth of the Industrial Revolution and steam-powered mills that were able to produce refined-grain flours that had significantly longer shelf lives, making flour (aka: gluten) more accessible and available to an almost global market. “We were able to mill and process grains for consumption and eat them in larger quantities than we had ever done in the past,” writes Cordain.

Jack Challem, “The Nutrition Reporter,” offers a different long view of human consumption of gluten: “Look at in another way, 100,000 generations of people were hunter-gatherers, 500 generations have depended on agriculture, and only 10 generations have lived since the start of the industrial age, and only two generations have grown up with highly processed fast foods. This short period of time in the course of man’s existence that grains have been around has proven that many of us are not physiologically able to tolerate gluten.”

Historical evidence of people having trouble digesting gluten was first documented in the 2nd century A.D. when the Greek physician Aretaeus of Cappadocia, diagnosed patients with celiac disease. The symptoms included “wasting and characteristic stools.” Since Aretaeus’ time, the disease has gone by a variety of names, including “non-tropical sprue,” “celiac sprue,” “non-celiac gluten intolerance,” “gluten intolerance enteropathy,” and “gluten sensitive enteropathy.”

Fast forward to 1950, when the Dutch pediatrician Willem-Karel Dicke proposed wheat gluten was the cause of the disease. His theory was based on observations that celiac children improved during World War II when wheat was scarce in Holland.

As Challem points out, today, thanks in large part to the fast food and snack food industries, gluten is in just about every kind of food imaginable.

So Why Can’t Everyone Handle Gluten?

People who carry any of the genes for CD and GI (expressed or not) are more susceptible to developing either condition. You can carry two dominate genes for celiac disease and perhaps end up developing CD or you can carry one dominant gene and one recessive gene and develop only GI. Your genes determine the body’s immune response in the presence of gluten, and many different health problems may result from that response. Some people may have their brain affected and develop cognitive problems such as depression or impaired brain function, while others suffer pancreatic problems and develop diabetes. Research still needs to be done to answer the question as to why these maladies affect different parts of the body in different people.

When populations that are genetically predisposed to CD and GI are exposed to cereal grains with higher gluten content, there’s little wonder why more people are having these genes “turned on” and develop gluten sensitivity on a much larger scale—especially now that the flour made from these grains are part of the “hidden ingredients” in foods from ice cream to lunch meats.

OK, Now What?

So, gluten has changed, and we have changed, and it appears not for the better. Fortunately or unfortunately, depending on how you look at it, identifying and eliminating the foods and ingredients from your life that do not work for your body is the only answer. There is no magic pill to take to make it all go away.

If you, or someone you know, is experiencing major health issues that aren’t getting better, enlisting a knowledgeable physician who understands the complexities of CD and GI testing is an excellent idea; however, on average, it takes the medical community 10 years to diagnose people who are suffering with severe health problems from undiagnosed CD and GI. 

The Bottom Line

Gluten intolerance is not a fad diet. I have seen countless cases display miraculous improvements in long standing ailments—simply by adapting this lifestyle. Even if you have a test for CD and it comes back negative and medical community clears you to continue eating gluten, but you feel better without it, listen to your body. You know yourself far better than anyone else and you deserve good health. If you have doubts about your diet, try going gluten-free for two weeks and see how you feel. Those with more advanced illnesses (autoimmune diseases and such) will usually not experience changes until they have been gluten-free for six months to a year.

Saturday, December 4, 2010

Gluten-free What is it? and Why I went there by Julie McGinnis, MS, RD

OPINION BY JULIE MCGINNIS

Good question.  The recent trend in gluten-free foods is allowing many to realize that gluten has not been good for their health. Aches clear up, inflammation goes away, headaches and migraines vanish, digestion improves, chronic anemia resolves, auto immune diseases go into remission,  etc. So, what key to wellness does a gluten-free diet hold? Many.  The two conditions improved by a gluten-free diet are celiac disease (CD) and gluten intolerance (GI). Celiac disease (CD) affects 1 out of 133 Americans, or about 3 million people. This autoimmune disorder is genetic and leaves one unable to digest gluten properly. The result of this autoimmune disorder is damage and flattening to the villi that are responsible for absorption of nutrients. Gl affects about 1 out every 10 people and it is an inability to digest gluten, much like lactose intolerance, and can result in much of the same health problems as those with CD. Ninety percent of those with CD are still undiagnosed and those with GI are usually diagnosing themselves.

Gluten is a protein found in wheat, barley and rye and in many cases oats due to cross contamination with wheat in processing. The list of forbidden foods is long, as wheat is found in many forms in many products. For a complete list of both safe and forbidden foods please visit www.theglutenfreegirl.com.  The theories as to why many of us feel better eating a gluten-free diet stem from a few areas of reason. One is that the wheat we have been eating for the last few decades that has been genetically modified to resist pests and drought, and with that change came an inability to digest the protein.  Along those lines according to substantial research done by Dr. Loren Cordain, PhD, author of The Paleo Diet, 10,000 years ago cereal grains were introduced into the diet as a result of the agricultural revolution. Until that time, for 2 million years, we were hunter gatherers. The foods that agriculture brought us –cereals, dairy products, fatty meats, salted foods, and refined sugars and oils- proved disastrous for our Paleolithic bodies. As well summarized by Jack Challem, The Nutrition Reporter, “Look at in another way, 100,000 generations of people were hunter-gatherers, 500 generations have depended on agriculture, and only 10 generations have lived since the start of the industrial age, and only two generations have grown up with highly processed fast foods. This short period of time in the course of man’s existence that grains have been around has proven that many of us are not physiologically able to tolerate gluten.

Going gluten-free can be a miracle for those living with chronic conditions that cannot be helped by medications or other therapies. Dr. Braly, author of Dangerous Grains, reports that undiagnosed sensitivities to gluten, gliadin, and other grain proteins are “the root cause of many cancers, autoimmune diseases, neurological diseases, chronic pain syndromes, psychiatric and other brain disorders, and premature death.” He further states, “There is also a clear causal connection with some cases of osteoporosis, epilepsy, learning disorders, attention deficit disorders, infertility, miscarriage, premature births, chronic liver disease, and short stature.” By avoiding all gluten containing foods for 10 days many can feel conditions improve and this is an easy way to see if gluten is indeed a problem for you.

These days the gluten-free world offers many great things; bread that actually toasts, bagels, and in some progressive areas pizza and pasta out in the restaurants. When shopping it is easy to fall prey to buying a lot of junk food gluten-free items that may taste good but offer no nutritional value. Many of the gluten-free flours used in main stream products lack vitamins and minerals. These flours are not fortified like wheat flour so try to choose products made with flours that are nutrient dense like buckwheat, brown rice, sorghum and coconut. These flours provide protein, fiber, B vitamins and minerals. It is important to eat a healthy diet and restore nutrient status in your body. GI and CD often deplete the body and leave many with less than optimal health.

Julie McGinnis, MS, RD, gluten-free 8 years
Owner, The Gluten Free Bistro
The Gluten Free Bistro (www.theglutenfreebistro.com)  offers a blog that converts many of Martha Stewart’s recipes to gluten-free and  supplys restaurants in Colorado, Utah and New Mexico.